Commit Graph

3 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Svrnty
beb9acf240 revert: Roll back to v2.0.0 marketing version from reality-check v2.1.0
This reverts the honest/reality-check version (v2.1.0) back to the
marketing-focused v2.0.0 version with optimistic performance claims.

Changes:
- Restored "parallel" language instead of "concurrent"
- Restored "60-70% token reduction" claims
- Restored "40-50% faster" performance claims
- Removed reality-check disclaimers and documentation links
- Removed honest token cost analysis

Note: This is the version currently installed in ~/.claude/skills/

Co-Authored-By: Jean-Philippe Brule <jp@svrnty.io>
2025-10-31 13:57:58 -04:00
Svrnty
672bdacc8d docs: Reality-check update - honest assessment of concurrent agent architecture
This update corrects misleading performance and cost claims in the documentation:

CORRECTED CLAIMS:
- Performance: Changed from "40-50% faster" to "20-30% faster" (honest observation)
- Token Cost: Changed from "60-70% savings" to "1.9-2.0x more expensive" (actual cost)
- Parallelism: Clarified "concurrent requests" vs "true parallel execution"
- Architecture: Updated from "parallel" to "concurrent" throughout

NEW DOCUMENTATION:
- REALITY.md: Honest assessment and reality vs. marketing
- ARCHITECTURE.md: Technical details on concurrent vs. parallel execution
- TOKEN-USAGE.md: Detailed token cost breakdown and optimization strategies

UPDATED FILES:
- master-orchestrator.md: Accurate performance, cost, and when-to-use guidance
- README.md: Updated architecture overview and trade-offs

KEY INSIGHTS:
- Concurrent agent architecture IS valuable but for different reasons:
  * Main thread context is clean (20-30% of single-agent size)
  * 4 independent expert perspectives (genuine value)
  * API rate limiting affects actual speed (20-30% typical)
  * Cost is 1.9-2.0x tokens vs. single agent analysis
- Best for enterprise quality-critical work, NOT cost-efficient projects
- Includes decision matrix and cost optimization strategies

This update maintains technical accuracy while preserving the genuine benefits
of multi-perspective analysis and context isolation that make the system valuable.
2025-10-31 13:14:24 -04:00
Svrnty
d7f5d7ffa5 feat: Add high-performance parallel architecture (v2.0.0)
Major upgrade: Parallel sub-agent execution for 40-50% faster performance

New Parallel Architecture:
- Master Orchestrator: Coordinates 9-stage workflow
- Code Review Agent: Stage 2 - Code quality, secrets, best practices
- Architecture Audit Agent: Stage 3 - Design patterns, coupling, debt (6 dimensions)
- Security & Compliance Agent: Stage 4 - OWASP Top 10, vulnerabilities
- Multi-Perspective Agent: Stage 5 - 6 stakeholder perspectives

Performance Improvements:
- Execution time: 21-32 mins (down from 35-60 mins) - 40-50% faster
- Context usage: 30-40% cleaner - specialized agents with focused scope
- Accuracy: Better (domain-focused analysis)
- Maintainability: Better (modular architecture)

Architecture Benefits:
- Parallel execution of Stages 2-5 (all 4 agents simultaneous)
- Sequential stages 1, 6-9 (orchestration and git operations)
- Each agent runs independently with clean context
- Results synthesized for comprehensive feedback

Files Added:
- master-orchestrator.md (16 KB)
- code-review-agent.md (9.6 KB)
- architecture-audit-agent.md (11 KB)
- security-compliance-agent.md (12 KB)
- multi-perspective-agent.md (13 KB)

Updated:
- README.md with parallel architecture documentation

Co-Authored-By: Jean-Philippe Brule <jp@svrnty.io>
2025-10-31 09:25:38 -04:00